Engineering used to dictate form, but times have changed. We meet Land Rover’s design boss to discover why style is now equal to substance
Steve Cropley Autocar
8 December 2018

Whatever your opinion of Land Rover design – and for most critics it’s distinctly warm – you can’t fault design director Gerry McGovern on the consistency of his philosophy. 

When he took the director’s job back in 2004 after a few years of designing American luxury cars (and the first Freelander before that), he explained his design motivation to Autocar with crystal clarity. “Land Rover’s roots are in pure design,” he declared. “It’s not just about styling.” 

On that score, nothing has changed. As we discovered during a conversation in the marque’s Gaydon ‘design garden’, McGovern is happy to re-state his philosophy as stridently as ever, despite all the water that has flowed under the bridge. Land Rovers are selling four times as well as they did when he first took the big job and today’s showrooms contain three or four more models than they did. Nevertheless, “visual durability” remains a core component of Land Rover appeal, even if you no longer need to stress it as you once did. 

“After I came back to Land Rover, I worked in advanced design,” says McGovern, “and it gave me a chance to get my thinking straight. I’d always liked the marque, going right back to that famous photograph of Winston Churchill with the Series One and the cigar. These were not machines for car enthusiasts, but everyone knew about their integrity. I liked their sheer depth of character. Land Rovers started off looking as they did because of what they could do – which was fine for the time but it meant design played second fiddle to engineering. 

Our Verdict

Range Rover Velar

Fourth Range Rover model has abundant style but how much breadth of ability does the Velar really have?

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

“My view was that if you wanted compelling, emotional, modern designs to last in production, design had to be an equal partner with engineering. So we changed it. Now we’re equal partners.” 

McGovern says he’s nowadays “joined at the hip” with Nick Rogers, Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) chief engineer, “even though we sometimes make life hard for him.” Modern engineers, he says with conviction, understand as well as anyone in the company the beneficial effect that appealing design has on sales. 

We’re at Gaydon, overlooked by a gigantic jumble of cranes and scaffolding as the adjacent engineering centre is rapidly reconfigured as a happy home for 12,000 inmates. As well as spending time with McGovern, my mission is to meet Land Rover’s chief designer, colour and materials, Amy Frascella, because Land Rover has rapidly become an influential leader in this vital area and American-born Fraschella is recognised as one of its foremost experts. 

Parked around us are four Land Rovers: a superb Series One from JLR’s Reborn operation; the actual LRX concept that wowed the world at Detroit in 2008 and rapidly turned into the rule-changing Evoque three years later; a mid-1970s two-door Range Rover (in the mustard colour that only ever looked good in this solitary application); and McGovern’s own motor of the moment, a matt-finish Range Rover in Byron Blue. A more disparate quartet would be hard to find. 

The two design chiefs are thus looking wary because they know our story’s remit is to gather their thoughts on why Land Rovers look the way they do, a gigantic question. It’s clear they’re not keen to grope for links between the machines they create today and cars from 1948, or even 1970. 

Yet it has to be asked: what do these Land Rover and Range Rover originals mean to my companions? McGovern, famous for having his head in the future, smiles a little wearily as he acknowledges a fondness for the classics and their contribution to Landie DNA, “though the world’s changed massively since then”. Frascella acknowledges the honesty and durability of materials in early cars and reckons their intended longevity still influences today’s materials choices. Neither designer puts it this way, but it’s pretty clear that as long as new Land Rover models acknowledge original marque values, and do them no actual harm, the job’s done. 

For both, the LRX is where true relevance to today begins. “This concept brought me into the brand,” says Frascella, who was working for a Korean brand at the time. “It was such a disrupter. I saw it in Geneva, and then as a production model in LA. It made me curious about what they’d be doing next.” 

Frascella’s major task today is recognising, and preferably setting, the colour and material trends of the future. She’s already well known for creating luxury interiors for a post-wood-and-leather audience and recently introduced a ‘premium textile’ called Kvadrat into the Velar as an alternative to leather. Buyers are nowadays very knowledgeable about the sources of their cars’ materials, she says, and there’s a shift in favour of reclaimed and non-leather materials in what she calls “post-industrial” colours. “Premium car customers still love luxury,” says Frascella, “but they’re also dialling back the consumerism and doing some good if they can.” 

McGovern makes the principles of good design sound deceptively simple. “It’s all about ideal volumes and proportions,” he says, brandishing two fascinatingly different profile illustrations of a current Range Rover, one as it should be, the other with incorrect details and proportions. They’re from a presentation McGovern often makes to Land Rover insiders selling the best design principles. 

The standard picture shows correct body overhangs (short front, longer rear), an ideal ship-in-full-sail stance, desirable (big) wheels and neat bodyside details that add class. The second is the same car on small wheels with its proportions all over the place. It so obviously lacks the balance and elegance of a Range Rover that, for McGovern, “it almost attacks the senses”. 

He says: “You still see plenty of cars that were engineered before they were designed and the risk is they come out like this. Design is about discipline. You have to do things the right way: first get the volumes and proportions right, then work on the stance, then make sure the surface development delivers the elegance you want, and then add details. Then it’s a matter of honing a new vehicle for production, a painstaking job. That’s very much a team effort, and it always has been.” 

Join the debate

Comments
11

8 December 2018
I do like his latest creations, even if they may look quite similar. Looking forward to seeing the new Defender.

8 December 2018

Steve Cropley + JLR + Gerry McGovern = the best of all possible worlds.

Cropley's uncritical pieces on JLR read increasingly like adverts.

Generally speaking I like McGovern's designs. But a Q&A that simply lets the interviewee promote himself without any meaningful input from the interviewer has no value.

8 December 2018

Agreed in general. McGovern has helped Land Rover deliver a number of popular and desirable models but it’s not all perfect.

This article doesn’t mention the forthcoming Defender, his biggest test yet and successor to the original Land Rover, an accidental design icon. The new one will be a very professional job, but not really fulfilling the same function as the original.

8 December 2018

I just dont get it, if they are so good, JLR should be the most profitable company on the planet, they effectively invented the SUV, have a large range of them, but cant seem to sell as many as they should be, the reason possibly, is that they all look the same, they are all competing against each other, they are overpriced, with average at best build quality and relability, and the less said about the latest Discovery the better, its a terrible design. The best thing JLR could do is replace McGovern and Callum, before the next generation vehicles are introduced/signed off, I suspect however its probably too late.  

8 December 2018

I don't think anyone can say anything other than that the Evoque was and is a great design (pleasing to the eye), and I loved the boxey Disco 4.  But come on, Disco 5?  And they all seem to be copies of one another, now.  The new Defender is just a shortened Disco 4...and that's good.  But it's hardly a million miles away from the DC100, which was also good, so I don't see what they've been doing all this time - they should have released the DC100.

I say my bit, then go. So although I'm interested in what you may initially say, I don't care what you think about what I've written, so I won't read whatever your reply is.

db

8 December 2018

The second picture explains why the Audi Q7 looks so awkward along with the Bentley version though neither is as bad as the Rolls Royce SUV effort shorlty to be ousted for top spot by the BMW X7. All goes to show badge wins out over aesthetics, luckily for the owners they only have to look art the interiors the rest of us are stuck looking at the exterior. A matter of more money than taste perhaps. 

8 December 2018
It's well known McGovern sneers at car enthusiasts. Just look at his posture when the last defender rolled off the line. Current cars do not look rugged and all look the same from the front. Furthermore they are not rugged and after 3 I may not be buying another until they make another rugged looking one that is rugged in reality and has some soul. Lastly, sales are actually down.

8 December 2018

Mr McGovern reckons he's concerned about the importance of a cars proportions, so what happened with the two latest releases?  Disco 5 is so heavy around the rear it looks as if it would end up with its front end pointing skyward if you put something in the boot, and the Velar only looks ok if viewed slightly from above. Maybe those two were designed by someone else whilst he was off on holiday

8 December 2018
I don't see how the chap can be expected to produce good designs if he dresses like that.

To answer why LR is going backwards fast, compare the Discovery 4 to the Discovery 5.

8 December 2018
The mutant Range Rover picture looks better than the Discovery 5.

Pages

Add your comment

Log in or register to post comments

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week